Room 20's Student Resources
Fourth Grade Writing Rubric


ADVANCED
PROFICIENT
BASIC BELOW BASIC FAR BELOW BASIC
6
5
4
3
2
1

Content

  • very clear, focused and interesting
  • content and details are well suited to purpose and audience
  • uses rich and varied vocabulary

Content

  • very clear, focused and interesting
  • presents topic with an understanding of the purpose and audience
  • uses a wide variety of words effectively

 

Content

  • clear, sticks to the topic
  • shows awareness of purpose and audience
  • uses a variety of words that are appropriate to the topic

Content

  • content somewhat understandable with some confusion
  • understanding of the purpose and audience not clear
  • uses limited variety of word choice

Content

  • unclear; has few appropriate details
  • some sense of audience and purpose inferred
  • uses simple, nonspecific vocabulary

Content

  • unclear and seems to have no purpose
  • seems unaware of purpose and audience
  • uses simple, repetitive vocabulary

Organization

  • multiple paragraph text with coherent organization
  • details are thoughtfully placed to strengthen message
  • writes an engaging, well-developed multiple paragraph composition with introductory, supporting and concluding paragraphs

Organization

  • multiple paragraph text presented in a well organized traditional structure
  • details fit and build on each other
  • writes an engaging, well-developed multiple paragraph composition with introductory, supporting and concluding paragraphs

Organization

  • multiple paragraph text using a traditional structure to convey information such as: 1) chronological order; 2) cause and effect; 3) similarity and difference; and 4) posing and answering a question.
  • details fit where they are placed
  • writes a multiple paragraph composition with introductory, supporting and concluding paragraphs

Organization

  • text shows limited traditional structure to convey information such as: 1) chronological order; 2) cause and effect; 3) similarity and difference; and 4) posing and answering a question.
  • some details don't fit
  • writes a multiple paragraph composition that lacks an introductory, supporting, or concluding paragraph

Organization

  • text very weakly organized with no underlying structure
  • details are confusing
  • writes a composition that is a single paragraph

Organization

  • text with no structural organization evident
  • little or no detail
  • writes a composition that lacks paragraph structure

Mechanics

  • generally free from minor errors in conventions characteristic of first draft writing
  • spells grade level appropriate words and many difficult words correctly
  • uses a variety of simple and compound sentences that are grammatically correct

Mechanics

  • clear control of conventions (may have a few errors but they do not distract)
  • spells grade level appropriate words and a few difficult words correctly
  • uses simple and compound sentences that are generally grammatically correct

Mechanics

  • good control of convention (grammar, spelling, capitalization, punctuation)
  • spells grade level appropriate words correctly and uses phonics to appropriate difficult words
  • spells correctly roots, inflections, suffixes, and prefixes, and syllable constructions
  • uses simple and compound sentences with few fragments or run-on sentences

Mechanics

  • frequent errors interfere with the flow of the writing and may cause confusion
  • spells some grade level appropriate words correctly, but makes some spelling errors that interfere with understanding
  • uses simple sentences generally free of grammatical errors

Mechanics

  • many serious problems in conventions (grammar, spelling, capitalization, punctuation)
  • spells many grade level appropriate words incorrectly
  • uses simple sentences with many grammatical errors

Mechanics

  • serious and persistent errors in almost every sentence
  • unreadable
  • does not make sentence
  • frequent spelling errors interfere with understanding
  • lacks sentence structure

(All of the above information was duplicated directly from the New Haven Unified School District's 4th Grade Writing materials and is in draft form. The date of the document is February 2001 and should not be duplicated or used by anyone outside of the school district. It is posted here for student, teacher and parent use. Thank you.)

 

Return to Mrs. Cirino's Homepage